FINANCIAL STRATEGY AS SUPPORT DETERMINANT FOR THE AVOIDANCE AND RESOLUTION OF DISTRESS IN THE NIGERIAN BANKING INDUSTRY

ABSTRACT

The banking sector is the bedrock of the Nigerian economy, and this industry is known to have contributed in no small measure to the development of the economy. This industry is the enabling hub of national and global payment systems, which  facilitates trade transactions within and amongst numerous national, regional and international economic units and by so doing; it enhances commerce, industry and exchange.  In performing these various functions in the enabling environment provided by the government through various fiscal, and monetary policies and reforms, this industry has been experiencing a phenomenal distress whereby the banking institutions could not meet their financial obligations to their customers and stakeholders,  which led to the liquidation of many banking institutions, lost of deposits by depositors, lost of   investments by many investors and the crisis of confidence by the general public. Various researchers and bodies including the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) and Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC) have done some works to solve this problem. The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has introduced various reforms, yet this problem persists. The objective of this work is to evaluate financial strategy as determinant for sustainable performance growth and an antidote to distress in the Nigerian banking industry.  The research method is empirical, and descriptive with the use of primary and secondary data from 1998-2007. Primary data were obtained from a sampled population through the use of a corporate questionnaire, and for the secondary, macro data were obtained from Central Bank and Nigerian Stock Exchange.  Multivariate Analysis of variance method (MANOVA) was applied in analyzing the primary data. The results revealed the homogeneity, co linearity, and strong interrelationship between the dependent variables and the independent variables to solve distress in the three types of banks analyzed. With the results obtained, all the five null hypotheses were nullified.  Multiple regression analysis was used to analyze the secondary data in conjunction with change in growth model. The results from the two statistical methods revealed a co-movement and correlation between Gross Domestic Product and Bank performance indices in the banking industry. A change in bank performance will have the same directional change in Gross Domestic Product as other sectors of the economy are also affected. The Bank performance indices are strong predictors of Gross Domestic Product. The work recommended a transformational financial strategy model in the work for implementation in the banking industry so that distress can be avoided and totally resolved. The model contains the following indices: sound corporate governance, good investment policy, effective capital budgeting, corporate planning, effective tax planning, effective budgetary control and economic profit of investment. An implementation of the model will give birth to sustainable performance growth which contains the following growth variables: adequate capital, quality earning assets, stable profitability, sustainable liquidity, enhanced dividend paid, and equitable tax liability. Other recommendations are: effective risk assets management, sound training of credit analyst, quality supervision from the industry regulators, and independence of EFCC for effectiveness. However, all stakeholders must be committed to the model and other recommendations.

                                                              TABLE OF CONTENTS

Chapter one:   Introduction

1.1 Background to the Study                                                                                 

1.2 Statement of the problem                                                                                

1.3 Objectives of the study                                                                                    

1.4 Research Questions                                                                                         

1.5 Statement of Hypotheses                                                                                 

1.6 Scope of Study                                                                                                  

1.7 Significance of Study                                                                                      

1.8 Preview of Research Methodology                                                                 

1.9 Operational Definition of Terms                                                                       

Chapter Two

Literature Review

2.1 Introduction                                                                                                     

2.2 The Evolution of Banking in Nigeria                                                               

2.2.1The Colonial Era (1892-1957)                                                                        

2.2.2The Independence Era (1957-1970)                                                               

2.2.3The Indigenous Era (1970-1985)                                                                   

2.2.4 The Privatization and Commercialization Era (1986-1992)                         

2.2.5Bank Rehabilitation and Restructuring Era (1992-date)                                 

2.2.6The Nature of Bank Reforms in Nigeria                                                        

2.3 Review of Literature relating to Financial Strategy and Sustainable

       Performance Growth                                                                         

2.3.1 Competing for the future                                                                

2.3.2 Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) and Nigeria Deposit Insurance

         Corporation (NDIC) definition of distress and analytical framework       

2.3.3 Strategic Planning and Sustainable Performance Growth                          

2.3.4 Financial Strategy in the Banking Industry                                                 

2.4 Review of Literature relating to Strategic Planning and Bank

      Performance for Sustainability and Growth in Nigerian Banking Industry  

2.4.1 Strategic planning: Financial performance relations in Banks: A causal

         examination                                                                                                   

2.4.2 Corporate Governance and Sustainable Performance Growth                     

          Cases of Poor Corporate Governance in Banks

           1. The Rumbles in Spring Bank                                                                                                               

           2. Development in Wema Bank Plc                                                            

           3. CBN Replaces Five Bank MDs, Directors                                              

2.4.3 Budgetary Control and Performance Evaluation                                           

2.4.4 Capital Budgeting and Sustainable Performance Growth                            

2.4.5 Tax Planning and liquidity                                                                            

2.4.6 Leadership and Sustainable Performance Growth                                        

2.5 Review of Literature relating to Investment Policies and

      Management of Assets and Liabilities in Nigeria Banking Industry                

2.5.1 A case study of distress banks in Nigeria by Central Bank of Nigeria         

2.5.2 Banking crisis: causes, early warning signals and resolutions                      

2.5.3 The causes of financial distress in local banks in Africa  and

          Prudential policy                                                                                           

2.5.4 Incentives and Resolution of Bank Distress                                                 

2.6 Review of Literature relating to Bank Performance and Gross Domestic  

      Product to Determine their Co-movement                                                        

2. 6.1 Economic Profit and Performance Measurement in the Banking Industry 

2.6.2 Banking practice and the Nigerian economy                                                

2.6.3 Micro and Macro Determinant of bank fragility in North Cyprus

         Economy                                                                                                       

2.7 Justification of study                                                                                        

2.8 Theoretical Framework                                                                                    

2.9.Framework Proposal:Causal Link between Model and Research Work         

Chapter Three   

 Research Methodology                                                                                                

3.1 Introduction                                                                                                     

3.2 Study Area                                                                                                        

3.3 Research Design                                                                                               

3.4 Population, Sample Representatives and Sampling Techniques                       

3.5 Performance Indices                                                                                          

3.6   Restatement of Hypotheses                                                                                    

3.7 Data Collection Techniques                                                                              

3.8 Reliability and Validity Test                                                                            

3.9 Data Administration                                                                                          

3.10 Method of Data Analysis                                                                                

3.11 Expected Results                                                                                             

3.13 Chapterization                                                                                                   

Chapter Four

Analysis and Interpretation of Data

4.1 Introduction                                                                                                      

4.2.Response to Questionnaire                                                                                 

4.3 Frequency Analysis of response to Questionnaire items                                    

4.3.1 Section1 Relationship between Financial strategy and Sustainable

       Performance                                                                                                       

4.3.2 Section2 Relationship between Strategic Planning and Performance

        For Sustainability of Growth of Business                                                        

4.3.3 Section 3Assessment of Investment Policy for Better Management of

         Assets and Liabilities in banks                                                                         

4.3.4 Section 4Evaluation of Relationship between Bank Performance and Gross

        Domestic Product (GDP)                                                                                 

4:4 Descriptive Analysis of response to Questionnaire items                                   

4.4.1Evaluation of the relationship between Financial Strategy and Sustainable

        Performance Growth                                                                                         

4.4.2 Evaluation of the relationship between Strategic Planning and Performance

        For Sustainability of Business Growth                                                            

4.4.3 Assessment of the relationship Investment Policy and Management of Assets

         and Liabilities for Sustainable Performance Growth in the Banking Industry

4.4.4 Evaluating the relationship between Bank Performance and GDP                  

4.5.0 Statistical Testing Model                                                                                   

4.5.1 Testing of Hypothesis       1                                                                              

4.5.2 Testing of Hypothesis       2                                                                               

4.5.3 Testing of Hypothesis       3                                                                              

4.5.4 Testing of Hypothesis       4                                                                               

4.5.5 Testing of Hypothesis       5                                                                              

4.6   Analysis of Secondary Data                                                                               

4.6.1 Multiple Regression                                                                                           

4.6.2 Analysis and Comparison of Growth Change in GDP and Bank

         Performance Indices                                                                                          

Chapter Five

Summary of Findings, Conclusion and Recommendations                                                 

5.1 Research Findings: Empirical Findings                                                              

5.2 Conclusion                                                                                                           

5.3 Recommendations                                                                                              

5.4 Suggestions for Further Studies                                                                         

5.5 Contribution to knowledge                                                                                  

              References                                                                                                   

                                                             CHAPTER ONE

INTRODUCTION

1.1          BACKGROUND TO THE STUDY

In the ordinary parlance, the word distress connotes unhealthy situation or state of inability or weakness which prevents the achievement of a set goals and aspirations. A financial institution will be described as unhealthy; when it exhibits severe financial, operational and managerial weaknesses where sustainability and stability are missing in business. A business is any activity that seeks to make profit by providing goods and services to the society by using inputs from the environment and transform them into outputs that add meaning to human existence. A business can be one’s regular employment, profession, occupation and can be an organization established through the pooling together of resources by various investors with the aim of providing products or services to the economy, contribute to the development of the economy and earn returns on their investments. Nigerian businesses can be classified into three major segments viz: Private enterprises, Private limited Liability Companies   and publicly quoted companies. The banking sector belongs to the private limited liability companies and the publicly quoted companies. While some banking institutions are privately owned by investors, some are publicly quoted on the Nigerian Stock Exchange. The banking sector is part of Nigerian financial system, and financial system refers to the totality of the regulatory and participating institutions, including financial markets and instruments, involved in the process of financial intermediation. The major objectives of investing in the banking sector are to provide financial services to the economy and earn compensatory returns on capital employed.

The Bills of Exchange Acts Cap 21, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria 1958 states that a ‘banker’ includes a body of persons whether incorporated or not who carry on the business of banking. By S.2 Coins Act Cap 34, laws of the Federation of Nigeria, 1958, bank and banker mean any persons, partnerships or company carrying on the business of bankers and also any saving bank established under the Saving Bank Ordinance, and also any banking company incorporated under any ordinance heretofore or hereafter passed relating to such incorporation. S.21 (1) Nigerian Evidence Act, Cap.62, laws of Federation of Nigeria, 1958, also provides in like manner. (Olulana, 1999:16). The Banks and other Financial Institutions Act No 25 of 1991 defines bank as one licensed under the Act and banking business as the business of receiving deposits on current, saving or other similar account, and paying or collecting cheques-S.62 BOFIA. The industry is the enabling hub of national and global payments system by   facilitating trade transactions within and amongst numerous national, regional and international economic units and by so doing; it enhances commerce, industry and exchange. The banking industry in Nigeria is the bedrock of the economy. 

According to Onoh (2002:10-13),the establishment of modern banking in Nigeria dates back to the colonial era when the African Banking Corporation was formed in 1892 to distribute currency notes of the Bank of England for the British treasury. Subsequent developments were encouraged by colonial entrepreneurs who needed banking institutions to back up the colonial trade. In the bid to address the credit needs of indigenous entrepreneurs, Nigerians later ventured into the banking business, initially through private individuals and later through deliberate government policy. According to CBN and NDIC (1995:1), the problem of distress in the financial sector, including bank failure, has been observed in Nigeria as far back as 1930 when the first bank failure was reported. Between 1930 and 1958 when Central Bank of Nigeria CBN was established, about 22 banks were liquidated (appendix 1). In 1992, 3banks were liquidated while in 1994, 4banks were liquidated. The degree of intensity and scope of the distress has never been as serious as has been observed since June,1989 when the Government directive to withdraw deposits of government and other public sector institutions from banks to the CBN exposed the weak financial condition of most financial institutions. This led to the increase in the number of distressed institutions and the severity of the problem has been on the increase. The intensity of the problem led to the liquidation of 26banks in 1998(appendix 2).

 According to CBN (2004:1), following the deregulation of the Nigerian financial sector in 1986 during era of structural adjustment programme (SAP), the banking industry witnessed remarkable growth, both in the number of deposit money banks and other types of financial institutions. However, in the early 1990s, Nigerian banking institutions faced many challenges, including increased competition and harsh economic conditions. Against this background, the incidence of financial sector distress induced by undercapitalization, liquidity crisis and high degree of non-performing loans characterized the banking industry in Nigeria. Some of the banks were faced with the threat of liquidation, while some were resuscitated as a result of the timely intervention of the regulatory authorities.  

Several measures have been taken by the supervisory agencies to tackle the problem of distress in the financial system most especially the banking industry to stem the deterioration in the financial conditions of ailing banks with the ultimate aim of restoring confidence in the financial system. These varied from financial assistance, imposition of holding actions and supervisory intervention to the outright liquidation of some distressed banks. As a way of minimizing the distress in the banking system, the Central Bank in 1990 introduced the Prudential Guidelines on early recognition of loan losses and required banks to make adequate provisions for bad and doubtful debts, a factor which was responsible for the insolvency of some banks.

 The Central Bank of Nigeria explained that based on bank examination reports, the supervisory authorities drew the attention of the Boards and Managements of distressed banks to a number of shortcomings such as poor credit policy, large portfolio of non-performing assets, weak internal controls, insider abuses. All the recommendations were unheeded. The regulatory authorities had to impose holding actions on such banks, the implementation of which was time bound.  The CBN in collaboration with the NDIC granted liquidity support to illiquid banks to assist them meet their obligations as and when due. This helped to achieve some measure of success and restore public confidence. Technical assistance was provided by the supervisory agencies in form of advisory services and secondment of staff when the need arose. Owing to limited success in the application of Holding Actions, the CBN assumed control and management of some distressed banks with the intention to acquire, restructure and subsequently sell them to the public. In order to sanitize the banking system and install market discipline, the licences of some banks were revoked in the system in 1992, 1994, 1998 and 2005.  

According to Eghodaghe (1993) and cited by CBN/NDIC (1995), a financial institution in distress is usually one where the evaluation depicts poor condition in all or most of the five performance factors as follows:

(a) Gross undercapitalization in relation to level of operation;

(b) High level of classified loans and advances;

(c) Illiquidity reflected in the inability to meet customers’ cash withdrawals;

(d) Low earnings resulting from huge operational losses, and

(e) Weak management as reflected by poor credit quality, inadequate internal controls, high rate of frauds and forgeries, labour turn-over, etc.

Based on the extent and depth of the problem, it is evident that Nigeria has been experiencing generalized type of distress. The generalized type of distress exists when its occurrence is spreading so fast and cut across all the sub-sectors of the industry but its depth, in terms of the ratio of total deposits of distressed institutions to total deposits of the industry; the ratio of total assets of distressed institutions to total assets of the industry; and the ratio of total branches of distressed institutions to total institutional branches of the industry; among others, has not adversely affected the confidence of the public in the financial system. This situation arose because of the highhandedness of the Board of Directors and Management of the various institutions. The Managing Directors and Chief Executive Officers of these banks had influencing and controlling power over operational issues which have breached the tenets of corporate governance. The four pillars of corporate governance of Accountability, Fairness, Transparency and Independence have been thrown into the dustbin. Non-compliance with monetary  and fiscal policies and regulatory authorities principles and regulations have resulted into abuse of power, lack of initiative to put in place good credit policies that will aid assets and liabilities management. Fraud and malpractices and poor lending habit have been introduced into the system despite all the efforts of the regulatory authorities to sanitize the system.   Despite the growth in business and volume of assets of these institutions, rather than performance growth sustainability, what is prevailing is performance deterioration and financial distress. The performance growth indices could not be sustained. The banking institutions failed to design on their own strategies that will bring sustainability   and stability into the system like developing strategies that critically measure and analyze performance indices of capital, assets quality,profitability,liquidity,didvidend paid and tax paid. In 2005 December, when the Central Bank of Nigeria concluded the consolidation exercise in the industry for a new reform and transformation, only the following banks had the financial capacity to meet the minimum capital base of   N25billion: First Bank Plc, Union Bank Plc, Zenith Bank Plc, Oceanic Bank Plc and Citibank Ltd. Others went into mergers and Acquisition options which eventually produced 25megabanks in the industry.  Fourteen (14) banks whose balance sheet did not possess any value for merger or acquisition were liquidated (appendix 3).

 According to Masi, (1981) cited in Agene, (1995: 56) “On the day of independence the financial system was underdeveloped and most of the complex ramifications which are integral to it today were not there. The Central Bank was only established two years before independence and up to that date, there was little or no regulation of the banking industry. Fiscal policy in colonial Nigeria was frankly rudimentary as most of the banks were foreign-owned and foreign managed, and their orientation was essentially foreign.  He further explained that the two decades preceding the country’s independence were therefore, a period of tremendous growth and development in this crucial sector of Nigeria economy. The Nigeria banking system may therefore be conceived as a network of monetary financial institutions which act together as a repository for the community’s wealth; the interbank financial markets i.e. foreign exchange and money markets, which provide a web of debt instruments; and the framework of laws and regulations which control the flow of money and credit in time and space.